Contact Us

  1. Eat
  2. Bottles
  3. Reviews for Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Anti-Colic Bottle
Reviews for

Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Anti-Colic Bottle

LOVE: 24 NEUTRAL: 16
REGRET: 13 WANT: 11

share this

what parents are saying

Nicole B.

what parents are saying

LOVE: 24 NEUTRAL: 16
REGRET: 13 WANT: 11
    • Shawna D.
    • West Mifflin , Pennsylvania

    I wasn’t a huge fan of these and neither was my son. They were harder to clean and the middle part never stayed in May 28, 2021

    • Tara T.
    • Mehoopany, Pennsylvania

    Hard to clean, leak, many parts that all have to be on just right Dec 22, 2020

  • There are 5 total pieces to wash. New parents don't have that kind of time. In 1 out of the 3 pack, a piece needed to be cut with scissors in order to work. Sometimes nipple still gets sucked inwardly Aug 19, 2020

  • I wanted these bottles so bad but the nipples are so soft that when baby sucks on them they depress in and become inverted so your constantly pulling the bottle out of the mouth. Aug 04, 2020

  • We love tommee tippee closer to nature, so we bought these to help our gassy baby. Baby hates them. There’s not valve in the nipple, so it collapses in her mouth and she’s unable to eat! May 07, 2020

  • Cleaning the pieces on this particular bottle was too much work. I didn’t see much of a difference while using them also. Mar 01, 2020

  • I was really excited for these bottles but I had too many issues with them so I gave them away. The bottles have too many parts and the nipples would constantly invert Feb 10, 2020

  • Easy to assemble and clean. A necessity for colicky babies! Milk can get stuck on the inner rim, so tough for the baby to get the last bit, but still great bottles! My breastfeeding baby loves these! Feb 03, 2020

    • Alex C.
    • United States of America

    Terrible bottle for my little one. The nipple tends to suck inwards and it leaks. Also did not notice a difference in air flow/colic. Jan 18, 2020

    • Renee S.
    • Taylorsville, North Carolina

    Game changer! No bellyaches or fussiness after feedings! Jan 14, 2020

  • The design of this bottle is really good the shape of the bottle is easy to hold. My baby accepts the nipple easily. Has a lot of parts but they are easy to clean. Dec 21, 2019

    • Ella D.
    • Lexington, Kentucky

    These bottles made a big difference in my daughter colic. Dec 19, 2019

  • Used these for awhile along with the dr brown bottles and it’s nothing special. Sometimes though the nipple gets stuck together and my baby gets frustrated during his feeding. Dec 09, 2019

    • Elora L.
    • Rock hill , South Carolina

    Only bottles that worked for my colicky, gassy little guy. Love them! Dec 01, 2019

  • This is my favorite bottle yet. My Brest feed baby takes with ease. This was amazing for colic and any gassy babies. Lots to pieces to clean but comes with small brush for small parts. Nov 06, 2019

  • Great bottles for breast fed babies. The nipples are so natural that my baby had no issue switching from breast to bottle. These also help with colic and the straw will turn colors if milk is too hot. Nov 05, 2019

  • We love tommee tippee bottles. My only complaint with these is I found the nipples collapse more so than the non-colic bottles. Jul 25, 2019

  • My far the best bottles I’ve used. I probably have 40 of these bottle. They’ve really helped my son’s spit up. The nipples are also great. Apr 07, 2019

  • My second choice to comotomo! However, these bottles are more widely available and affordable. Mar 12, 2019

  • These bottles leak! Nov 02, 2018

    • ana H.
    • Houston , Texas

    does not come in extra slow nozzle Oct 03, 2018

  • LO did not like these at all, the flow was to slow she kept throwing them and refusing her bottle unless it was in a dr. browns Jul 07, 2018

  • These bottles are great at reducing gas. A bit cumbersome to clean but very much worth it. Baby also has a very easy time holding them as she is now self feeding. Used since about 3mo. Jul 03, 2018

    • Alys R.
    • Covington, Georgia

    I got the newborn set which included 2 small bottles, 2 larger bottles and a pacifier. We love them. Apr 27, 2018

  • Didn’t work for my baby and the nipple flow was way to fast for her. Apr 20, 2018

    • Rene V.
    • Bell Gardens, California

    Work great Apr 19, 2018

  • I love these bottles !! great for breastfeeding / pumping mothers. Easy transition for baby/ no nipple confusion. Never has my baby gassy. Used from birth Apr 13, 2018

  • Great colic free bottle! Feb 21, 2018

  • We used these with my daughter and they were great! The wide neck is great for formula and bottles are easy to clean. Feb 21, 2018

  • These were OK, lots of parts to clean and don't know if they really helped prevent gas. Seems more like a gimmick. Feb 19, 2018

  • My son has very bad reflux problems and I was hoping these would help. It appears that he drinks a little slower with this bottle but I’m not sure that it helps as advertised. Feb 09, 2018

  • I like these bottles because of the shape and feel of them. My daughter likes them as well. I'm not a fan of the nipples because they cave in easily and the anti-colic parts are a pain to clean. Feb 03, 2018

  • My baby loves these bottles. I think the anti colic portion helps some with gas but I haven't seen a huge difference between these and the regular tommee tippee bottles Dec 07, 2017

  • These were terrible. We used them a few times and every single time they would leak, every single time. We promptly returned them. Oct 25, 2017

  • These are the only bottles my baby took. She loved them, and never got gas or had excessive spit up from them. Oct 18, 2017

  • I first used these with my first one and they were easy and helped so much that i ended up buying them this time around for our second one! Oct 18, 2017

  • these were fine, baby just didn't like them as much. Aug 02, 2017

  • Bought the newborn starter set and then proceeded to buy 2 more 3 pks of the 9oz bottles. Anticolic straws do their job!! Jan 18, 2017

    • Kami S.
    • United States of America

    Don't bother, the anti colic piece does nothing, and MUST be in place, and ring screwed in exactly right, or the bottle leaks. Mar 16, 2016

See More Reviews

(including your friends’ reviews!)

More Parents' Reviews
    • Shawna D.
    • West Mifflin , Pennsylvania

    I wasn’t a huge fan of these and neither was my son. They were harder to clean and the middle part never stayed in May 28, 2021

    • Tara T.
    • Mehoopany, Pennsylvania

    Hard to clean, leak, many parts that all have to be on just right Dec 22, 2020

  • There are 5 total pieces to wash. New parents don't have that kind of time. In 1 out of the 3 pack, a piece needed to be cut with scissors in order to work. Sometimes nipple still gets sucked inwardly Aug 19, 2020

  • I wanted these bottles so bad but the nipples are so soft that when baby sucks on them they depress in and become inverted so your constantly pulling the bottle out of the mouth. Aug 04, 2020

  • We love tommee tippee closer to nature, so we bought these to help our gassy baby. Baby hates them. There’s not valve in the nipple, so it collapses in her mouth and she’s unable to eat! May 07, 2020

  • Cleaning the pieces on this particular bottle was too much work. I didn’t see much of a difference while using them also. Mar 01, 2020

  • I was really excited for these bottles but I had too many issues with them so I gave them away. The bottles have too many parts and the nipples would constantly invert Feb 10, 2020

  • Easy to assemble and clean. A necessity for colicky babies! Milk can get stuck on the inner rim, so tough for the baby to get the last bit, but still great bottles! My breastfeeding baby loves these! Feb 03, 2020

    • Alex C.
    • United States of America

    Terrible bottle for my little one. The nipple tends to suck inwards and it leaks. Also did not notice a difference in air flow/colic. Jan 18, 2020

    • Renee S.
    • Taylorsville, North Carolina

    Game changer! No bellyaches or fussiness after feedings! Jan 14, 2020

  • The design of this bottle is really good the shape of the bottle is easy to hold. My baby accepts the nipple easily. Has a lot of parts but they are easy to clean. Dec 21, 2019

    • Ella D.
    • Lexington, Kentucky

    These bottles made a big difference in my daughter colic. Dec 19, 2019

  • Used these for awhile along with the dr brown bottles and it’s nothing special. Sometimes though the nipple gets stuck together and my baby gets frustrated during his feeding. Dec 09, 2019

    • Elora L.
    • Rock hill , South Carolina

    Only bottles that worked for my colicky, gassy little guy. Love them! Dec 01, 2019

  • This is my favorite bottle yet. My Brest feed baby takes with ease. This was amazing for colic and any gassy babies. Lots to pieces to clean but comes with small brush for small parts. Nov 06, 2019

  • Great bottles for breast fed babies. The nipples are so natural that my baby had no issue switching from breast to bottle. These also help with colic and the straw will turn colors if milk is too hot. Nov 05, 2019

  • We love tommee tippee bottles. My only complaint with these is I found the nipples collapse more so than the non-colic bottles. Jul 25, 2019

  • My far the best bottles I’ve used. I probably have 40 of these bottle. They’ve really helped my son’s spit up. The nipples are also great. Apr 07, 2019

  • My second choice to comotomo! However, these bottles are more widely available and affordable. Mar 12, 2019

  • These bottles leak! Nov 02, 2018

    • ana H.
    • Houston , Texas

    does not come in extra slow nozzle Oct 03, 2018

  • LO did not like these at all, the flow was to slow she kept throwing them and refusing her bottle unless it was in a dr. browns Jul 07, 2018

  • These bottles are great at reducing gas. A bit cumbersome to clean but very much worth it. Baby also has a very easy time holding them as she is now self feeding. Used since about 3mo. Jul 03, 2018

    • Alys R.
    • Covington, Georgia

    I got the newborn set which included 2 small bottles, 2 larger bottles and a pacifier. We love them. Apr 27, 2018

  • Didn’t work for my baby and the nipple flow was way to fast for her. Apr 20, 2018

    • Rene V.
    • Bell Gardens, California

    Work great Apr 19, 2018

  • I love these bottles !! great for breastfeeding / pumping mothers. Easy transition for baby/ no nipple confusion. Never has my baby gassy. Used from birth Apr 13, 2018

  • Great colic free bottle! Feb 21, 2018

  • We used these with my daughter and they were great! The wide neck is great for formula and bottles are easy to clean. Feb 21, 2018

  • These were OK, lots of parts to clean and don't know if they really helped prevent gas. Seems more like a gimmick. Feb 19, 2018

  • My son has very bad reflux problems and I was hoping these would help. It appears that he drinks a little slower with this bottle but I’m not sure that it helps as advertised. Feb 09, 2018

  • I like these bottles because of the shape and feel of them. My daughter likes them as well. I'm not a fan of the nipples because they cave in easily and the anti-colic parts are a pain to clean. Feb 03, 2018

  • My baby loves these bottles. I think the anti colic portion helps some with gas but I haven't seen a huge difference between these and the regular tommee tippee bottles Dec 07, 2017

  • These were terrible. We used them a few times and every single time they would leak, every single time. We promptly returned them. Oct 25, 2017

  • These are the only bottles my baby took. She loved them, and never got gas or had excessive spit up from them. Oct 18, 2017

  • I first used these with my first one and they were easy and helped so much that i ended up buying them this time around for our second one! Oct 18, 2017

  • these were fine, baby just didn't like them as much. Aug 02, 2017

  • Bought the newborn starter set and then proceeded to buy 2 more 3 pks of the 9oz bottles. Anticolic straws do their job!! Jan 18, 2017

    • Kami S.
    • United States of America

    Don't bother, the anti colic piece does nothing, and MUST be in place, and ring screwed in exactly right, or the bottle leaks. Mar 16, 2016

No questions yet.
OTHER PRODUCTS WEELOVE

about us

weeSpring helps you share advice with your friends about the best baby bottles, softest swaddle blankets, most portable high chairs and everything else your family needs.

We also hand-pick the most innovative, game-changing products for parents, babies, and toddlers and deliver them to your email inbox with weeLove.
Sign Up >