See All
Strollers - All
See All
See All
See All
See All
See All
See All
See All
Strollers - All
See All
See All
See All
See All
See All
See All

Contact Us
  1. Sleep
  2. Pacifiers
  3. Reviews for First Years GumDrop Pacifier
Reviews for

First Years GumDrop Pacifier

LOVE: 148 NEUTRAL: 100
REGRET: 70 WANT: 29

share this

what parents are saying

First Years GumDrop Pacifier

Emily K.

as seen on weelists

Save This Buy Buy

what parents are saying

LOVE: 148 NEUTRAL: 100
REGRET: 70 WANT: 29

  • My daughter's favorite Pacifier. Had to buy several for backups! Apr 01, 2023

  • The ONLY pacifier our 1 child would take. Every kiddo is so different, I'm just glad this worked for her! Feb 24, 2023

  • I find these are just a little to hard. Not my favorite Feb 02, 2023

  • We were given these in the hospital and my baby wouldn’t take it. Seems the nipple is almost too small? Jan 17, 2023

  • These are the only pacifiers that my child would use. Dec 30, 2022

See More Reviews

(including your friends’ reviews!)
Featured Parents' Reviews

  • My son always sucked on a similar paci like this but out grew it. I came across this one and thought I give it a try since the nipple is similar to his out grown one. He took to it right away. May 19, 2020

  • Love the fact that they don't roll. Jul 11, 2019

  • My son wouldn’t take a pacifier. Don’t buy too many before your LO arrives. May 04, 2019

  • We used these before transitioning to the soothies. I love that they were smaller and a perfect size for a newborn. Apr 06, 2019

  • My little one would have it flipped upside down, so the nose indent would be at the chin- and didn’t care how it was facing. Loved these rounded pacifiers. Cheap and good quality silicone. Dec 17, 2018

  • These were always a great and affordable backup to the pacifiers my kids preferred. They were just a tad harder to clean than the Avent ones my kids liked but I would definitely keep these around! Oct 17, 2018

  • This was the only binky my baby would take. I think he liked that the nipple was similar to a bottle. I also liked the silcone material it is made out of. Dec 28, 2017

  • They are easy to clean and don’t collect mold. Perfect for newborns. Nov 28, 2017

  • My kids didn't not like these even after several tries. I am glad cuz everytime we were using them there blanket lint or fuzz would stick to these like a magnet. Nov 09, 2017

  • I loved the shape of these and their one piece design although none of our kids would take them. Oct 06, 2017

  • My son wasn't a fan. He liked the soothies more Sep 28, 2017

  • I received this in the NICU, meaning their good pacifiers. My daughter did like it, and I like how theres room for breathing under the nose. Aug 08, 2017

    • Tommy B.

    • Rapid City, South Dakota

    Our baby loves these and soothes him when crying. Jun 21, 2017

  • These were a little bulky with a smaller infant. May 14, 2017

    • Jenn M.

    • Northeast, Wisconsin

    These pacifiers are really bulky and thick. They seem a little heavy for my LO. May 13, 2017

  • I guess these were too small for my daughter to suck on ? They kept falling right out if her mouth and it made her frustrated trying so hard to suck on the paci to try to get a grip on it and failed May 09, 2017

  • These are really heavy. My son was not a fan! May 05, 2017

  • My daughter hardly used this pacifier. It seemed too small perhaps? She preferred other brands May 05, 2017

  • Baby doesn't like pacifiers but therapist said she needs for oral strength training. I love the soft silicone and the little dip makes me not worry about her breathing. Small tab helps w/resistance pull Apr 07, 2017

  • Got these for my oldest two, but they never took a pacifier. Feb 27, 2017

  • I love these binkys. My son had no problem with them, he started using day one at the hospital with no problems. Jan 26, 2017

  • I love these simple little pacifiers. They are perfect for use from day one and are easy to clean. A win win for us! Dec 21, 2016

  • Pacifier was made well and I like that it was one piece. My LO's didn't seem to take to it though. Ended up not using them. Jul 29, 2016

  • My kids only liked these and the Phillips Soothies. The curve makes it stay in their mouth, but it also makes it hard for little babes to orient them correctly into their mouths to suck on. May 08, 2016

  • I thought these would be wonderful but my girls could never keep them in their mouths. The hospital I used to work at used these for all their newborns. May 07, 2016

  • My son got his first from the hospital. I like being able to stick my finger in it amd move it around a little to get babys interest. Feb 29, 2016

  • I ended up throwing out all my pacifiers except these and soothies. I was so tired of trapped water! These are good and easy to clean. Feb 11, 2016

  • awkward shape and baby hated them Feb 01, 2016

  • Both boys hated these. They couldn't keep them in their mouth. Feb 01, 2016

  • This was the ONLY pacifier that worked for our infant. Rejected all others. Thankfully he went back to sucking his fingers. Jan 31, 2016

  • A little on the small side, they didn't work for my baby. Jan 29, 2016

  • These pacifiers were great for my newborn. As she got older she preferred the Nuk brand. Dec 04, 2015

  • Too hard for my daughter to keep in her mouth. Needs a bit more give so she can keep the suction. Jul 15, 2015

  • I love this pacifier! We have several of them around the house, diaper bag, and car. The shape is great for little noses. Mar 12, 2015

  • These are fantastic, he loves them. Dec 07, 2014

  • Didn't cause nipple confusion or interfere with nursing at all. She loves them and now will only take this brand. Oct 28, 2014

  • My daughter has NEVER been able to keep these in her mouth b/c of how heavy they are. She has to suck very hard to keep them in her mouth and as soon as she falls asleep, they fall out, she wakes up): Sep 24, 2014

  • We tried theses pacifiers with our daughter and she hated them. Always spit them out. Aug 05, 2014

  • We have the gumdrops, but it's the orange latex(?) version we got free at the hospital. Our son didn't take the hard plastic green and blue ones. Jun 19, 2014

    • Kali P.

    • Everett, Washington

    My son still doesn't keep his binky in his mouth on his own, but this one he will keep in the longest and is happiest with! Feb 06, 2014

  • My LO loves these & had no issues with nipple confusion. Feb 04, 2014

  • these were the brand given to us by the hospital for both babies. we've tried other brands, but this is the only one either would take! i throw them in the dishwasher and sterilize with bottle nipples Feb 03, 2014

  • The one-piece design makes these easy to clean. There are no crevices that can get gunky. Jan 09, 2014

  • Our little girl won't use any other pacifier. Plus, it's kinda cute being able to see them sucking on it. *laughs* Jun 21, 2013

  • these seemed to fall out the least of any paciifer we tried. Feb 07, 2013

More Parents' Reviews

  • My daughter's favorite Pacifier. Had to buy several for backups! Apr 01, 2023

  • The ONLY pacifier our 1 child would take. Every kiddo is so different, I'm just glad this worked for her! Feb 24, 2023

  • I find these are just a little to hard. Not my favorite Feb 02, 2023

  • We were given these in the hospital and my baby wouldn’t take it. Seems the nipple is almost too small? Jan 17, 2023

  • These are the only pacifiers that my child would use. Dec 30, 2022

No questions yet.
OTHER PRODUCTS WEELOVE

about us

weeSpring helps you share advice with your friends about the best baby bottles, softest swaddle blankets, most portable high chairs and everything else your family needs.

We also hand-pick the most innovative, game-changing products for parents, babies, and toddlers and deliver them to your email inbox with weeLove.
Sign Up >