Contact Us

  1. Sleep
  2. Pacifiers
  3. Reviews for Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Soother Pacifier BPA-Free Breast-Like Shape, White & Ice Blue, 6-18 Months, 4 Count
Reviews for

Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Soother Pacifier BPA-Free Breast-Like Shape, White & Ice Blue, 6-18 Months, 4 Count

LOVE: 36 NEUTRAL: 25
REGRET: 7 WANT: 10

share this

what parents are saying

Jessica S.

what parents are saying

LOVE: 36 NEUTRAL: 25
REGRET: 7 WANT: 10
  • My baby will spit these right back. Out she never really liked them. They are too slippery or something and she can’t get a good grip. Nov 14, 2023

  • The only pacifiers my exclusively breastfed baby will use Nov 05, 2023

  • This is the only pacifier, my breast-fed baby would take saved me a lot of time at night from just being his pacifier, save your money by the pacifier before you buy anything else Oct 04, 2023

    • Kim M.
    • North Sioux City, South Dakota

    Love this. I have 4 Sep 21, 2023

  • These are the only pacifiers my daughter will use, we've tried other brands but she just spits them out. Definitely a good purchase. Sep 17, 2023

  • The first pacifier my baby would take Sep 01, 2023

  • These are great, especially for breastfed babies die to the shape! They look super cute too, Jun 26, 2023

    • Allie J.
    • United States of America

    Closest baby came to showing interest in a pacifier after 3 months. Jun 14, 2023

  • My son’s favorite pacifier! This is the only one that truly calms him down when he is at his most fussy. He is breastfed and I really think the shape of the nipple is why he likes this one the best. Jun 02, 2023

  • Our guy had these for awhile and loved them but now wont take them anymore. Great price point for what you get. Simple and sturdy! Apr 21, 2023

  • Even though this is shaped to mimic the bottle nipple, which my son loves, it was not great. Our baby would gag on this for some reason. Mar 09, 2023

  • Love them! Definitely recommend to everyone!! Nov 23, 2022

  • The only pacifier my daughter would take as a newborn. Easy to clean, and lightweight Nov 18, 2022

  • THE FAVORITE for our kiddo, and the other baby in our baby share loves to chew this as well. Nov 09, 2022

  • I love using these for my breastfed baby! The base is different from others and more like a boob, so I really think it helps with any nipple confusion. Just wish they were a little easier to hold Oct 17, 2022

  • This Was The First Pacifier My Baby Sort Of Took. It Soothed Her Since It Was Shaped Like A Bottle Nipple But She Didn't Take It For Long. Jun 26, 2022

  • My baby wouldn’t take these—she only likes their ultralight ones. Jun 25, 2022

    • Kana N.
    • Naperville , Illinois

    These were so easy to wash and place onto a paci clip. Apr 10, 2022

  • Baby would just not take to them. Mar 02, 2022

  • Baby loved these when she first came home but it was very hard for her to keep them in her mouth due to them being king of big Feb 11, 2022

  • Our baby would not take these soothers. She much prefers the classic style. Dec 11, 2021

  • My baby just didn’t take it Nov 10, 2021

  • Baby hates this one.. she will cry continuously when I gave it to her, I guess she was just used to the other soother we used before, but it is well made and soft. Oct 08, 2021

  • Very nice lightweight and vented pacifier. The nipple is pretty large but compressible. Unfortunately my daughter was not a fan. Sep 26, 2021

  • These are the most breast like indeed. It took a little adjustment with the transition from maam but my baby’s latch on the breast is better after switching. Jul 26, 2021

  • my son loves these. they do fall out in his sleep quite easily Jun 21, 2021

    • Laura W.
    • Sacramento, California

    My son absolutely hated these pacifiers. He would spit them out immediately. I think the pacifiers are very baby specific and likely the best thing to do is buy several types and try them out. May 31, 2021

  • My son loves these paci's! They stay in well because they are light, and a bonus is they glow in the dark so you can find it in the middle of the night after it falls out of their mouth! Jan 20, 2021

  • I bought these off my registry myself! We want to breastfeed while also offer a paci and these seemed to be the best option based on reviews online. Fingers crossed. Dec 16, 2020

  • My son hates pacifiers and this was one of the two he would take! Nov 19, 2020

  • The best pacifier out there! We tried many different ones and this is the only one my breastfed baby would take. Oct 05, 2020

  • My daughter struggled to successfully latch from the very beginning of breast feeding, she wouldn't open up wide enough. Same issue with these, she won't open up and actively suck to keep these in. Aug 15, 2020

    • Haley S.
    • Allison Park, Pennsylvania

    These are the pacifiers my baby uses currently. She never had an issue with these pacifiers and I have always heard great reviews about them! Apr 09, 2020

  • These are the only pacifiers that my exclusively breastfed baby will take. They’re great! It’s nice because it’s super easy to to put a pacifier clip on through the slit...we use a silicone beaded one Mar 16, 2020

  • These are a sometimes taken pacifier in our house. Some days, my son loves them, others not as much. I really appreciate how easy they are to clean but found it difficult to put them on a clip. Feb 11, 2020

  • My twins love these pacifiers! They're really cute too Feb 10, 2020

  • I love these!! I breast feed my daughter and these are the closest thing to a breast nipple, she loved these pacifiers. Feb 05, 2020

    • Jess T.
    • Hotchkiss, Colorado

    We have tried a couple different pacifiers and these are my daughters favorite! Jan 25, 2020

  • baby doesn't seem to like these. Are a little too big and don't keep her interest long Just doesn't look comfortable. Jan 02, 2020

  • These are now my favorite pacifier. Baby took to them right away! They are extremely easy to clean and they do not trap water inside. They seem like a great option for breast fed babies Dec 04, 2019

  • I have tried almost every kind of pacifier and this is the only kind my breastfed son will ever take! I love these! Nov 15, 2019

  • Love how natural these pacifiers are. Great for breastfeeding babies and babies that use the Tommee Tippee bottles. Nov 05, 2019

See More Reviews

(including your friends’ reviews!)

More Parents' Reviews
  • My baby will spit these right back. Out she never really liked them. They are too slippery or something and she can’t get a good grip. Nov 14, 2023

  • The only pacifiers my exclusively breastfed baby will use Nov 05, 2023

  • This is the only pacifier, my breast-fed baby would take saved me a lot of time at night from just being his pacifier, save your money by the pacifier before you buy anything else Oct 04, 2023

    • Kim M.
    • North Sioux City, South Dakota

    Love this. I have 4 Sep 21, 2023

  • These are the only pacifiers my daughter will use, we've tried other brands but she just spits them out. Definitely a good purchase. Sep 17, 2023

  • The first pacifier my baby would take Sep 01, 2023

  • These are great, especially for breastfed babies die to the shape! They look super cute too, Jun 26, 2023

    • Allie J.
    • United States of America

    Closest baby came to showing interest in a pacifier after 3 months. Jun 14, 2023

  • My son’s favorite pacifier! This is the only one that truly calms him down when he is at his most fussy. He is breastfed and I really think the shape of the nipple is why he likes this one the best. Jun 02, 2023

  • Our guy had these for awhile and loved them but now wont take them anymore. Great price point for what you get. Simple and sturdy! Apr 21, 2023

  • Even though this is shaped to mimic the bottle nipple, which my son loves, it was not great. Our baby would gag on this for some reason. Mar 09, 2023

  • Love them! Definitely recommend to everyone!! Nov 23, 2022

  • The only pacifier my daughter would take as a newborn. Easy to clean, and lightweight Nov 18, 2022

  • THE FAVORITE for our kiddo, and the other baby in our baby share loves to chew this as well. Nov 09, 2022

  • I love using these for my breastfed baby! The base is different from others and more like a boob, so I really think it helps with any nipple confusion. Just wish they were a little easier to hold Oct 17, 2022

  • This Was The First Pacifier My Baby Sort Of Took. It Soothed Her Since It Was Shaped Like A Bottle Nipple But She Didn't Take It For Long. Jun 26, 2022

  • My baby wouldn’t take these—she only likes their ultralight ones. Jun 25, 2022

    • Kana N.
    • Naperville , Illinois

    These were so easy to wash and place onto a paci clip. Apr 10, 2022

  • Baby would just not take to them. Mar 02, 2022

  • Baby loved these when she first came home but it was very hard for her to keep them in her mouth due to them being king of big Feb 11, 2022

  • Our baby would not take these soothers. She much prefers the classic style. Dec 11, 2021

  • My baby just didn’t take it Nov 10, 2021

  • Baby hates this one.. she will cry continuously when I gave it to her, I guess she was just used to the other soother we used before, but it is well made and soft. Oct 08, 2021

  • Very nice lightweight and vented pacifier. The nipple is pretty large but compressible. Unfortunately my daughter was not a fan. Sep 26, 2021

  • These are the most breast like indeed. It took a little adjustment with the transition from maam but my baby’s latch on the breast is better after switching. Jul 26, 2021

  • my son loves these. they do fall out in his sleep quite easily Jun 21, 2021

    • Laura W.
    • Sacramento, California

    My son absolutely hated these pacifiers. He would spit them out immediately. I think the pacifiers are very baby specific and likely the best thing to do is buy several types and try them out. May 31, 2021

  • My son loves these paci's! They stay in well because they are light, and a bonus is they glow in the dark so you can find it in the middle of the night after it falls out of their mouth! Jan 20, 2021

  • I bought these off my registry myself! We want to breastfeed while also offer a paci and these seemed to be the best option based on reviews online. Fingers crossed. Dec 16, 2020

  • My son hates pacifiers and this was one of the two he would take! Nov 19, 2020

  • The best pacifier out there! We tried many different ones and this is the only one my breastfed baby would take. Oct 05, 2020

  • My daughter struggled to successfully latch from the very beginning of breast feeding, she wouldn't open up wide enough. Same issue with these, she won't open up and actively suck to keep these in. Aug 15, 2020

    • Haley S.
    • Allison Park, Pennsylvania

    These are the pacifiers my baby uses currently. She never had an issue with these pacifiers and I have always heard great reviews about them! Apr 09, 2020

  • These are the only pacifiers that my exclusively breastfed baby will take. They’re great! It’s nice because it’s super easy to to put a pacifier clip on through the slit...we use a silicone beaded one Mar 16, 2020

  • These are a sometimes taken pacifier in our house. Some days, my son loves them, others not as much. I really appreciate how easy they are to clean but found it difficult to put them on a clip. Feb 11, 2020

  • My twins love these pacifiers! They're really cute too Feb 10, 2020

  • I love these!! I breast feed my daughter and these are the closest thing to a breast nipple, she loved these pacifiers. Feb 05, 2020

    • Jess T.
    • Hotchkiss, Colorado

    We have tried a couple different pacifiers and these are my daughters favorite! Jan 25, 2020

  • baby doesn't seem to like these. Are a little too big and don't keep her interest long Just doesn't look comfortable. Jan 02, 2020

  • These are now my favorite pacifier. Baby took to them right away! They are extremely easy to clean and they do not trap water inside. They seem like a great option for breast fed babies Dec 04, 2019

  • I have tried almost every kind of pacifier and this is the only kind my breastfed son will ever take! I love these! Nov 15, 2019

  • Love how natural these pacifiers are. Great for breastfeeding babies and babies that use the Tommee Tippee bottles. Nov 05, 2019

No questions yet.
OTHER PRODUCTS WEELOVE

about us

weeSpring helps you share advice with your friends about the best baby bottles, softest swaddle blankets, most portable high chairs and everything else your family needs.

We also hand-pick the most innovative, game-changing products for parents, babies, and toddlers and deliver them to your email inbox with weeLove.
Sign Up >